By Illinois Review
Illinois House Republicans voted behind closed doors Tuesday evening to re-elect Minority Leader Tony McCombie (R-Savanna), raising questions about transparency, accountability and the taxpayer-funded bonuses associated with leadership positions in Springfield.
McCombie defeated State Rep. Regan Deering (R-Decatur) by a vote of 20-13, with one member declining to support either candidate, securing another two years as leader despite significant Republican losses in the November 3 election.
But while the final vote totals were disclosed, individual lawmakers’ votes remain secret.
That leaves Republican constituents unable to determine whether their elected representatives supported McCombie or voted for a change in leadership.
And with leadership appointments carrying additional taxpayer-funded stipends exceeding $10,000 annually, the secret-ballot process raises another question: Should lawmakers be able to conceal their leadership votes while potentially benefiting financially from appointments made by the leader they elect?
The issue surfaced before Tuesday’s election when conservative activist Jacqueline Garretson questioned an Illinois House Republican about the upcoming vote.
According to Garretson, the lawmaker resisted disclosing their intentions.
“I don’t really think I need to tell anybody how I plan to vote. No offense. I’m going to do what I feel is best for the caucus and my district,” the legislator reportedly told her.
The lawmaker later added:
“I don’t think I need to tell anyone how I intend to vote before I actually vote. A lot of things can change before then. That’s not ‘elitist,’ that’s pragmatic.”
Garretson challenged that response, arguing that elected officials should welcome questions from their constituents.
“When you say a lot of things can change before the vote, it leaves the door open to the possibility of backroom negotiations, political favors, or deals that could influence how someone ultimately votes,” she wrote.
“This was never about demanding that you disclose your vote or trying to control your decision. It was about transparency, accountability, and the expectation that those who serve in elected office remember who they answer to.”
Beyond transparency, the leadership election carries financial implications.
Under Illinois law, certain legislative leadership positions receive additional annual compensation beyond a lawmaker’s regular salary.
According to the Illinois General Assembly Compensation Act, 25 ILCS 115/1, statutory stipends include at least $10,500 annually for assistant minority leaders and $11,500 for deputy minority leaders, with actual amounts potentially higher due to compensation adjustments.
As House Republican Leader, McCombie controls appointments to leadership positions and has significant influence over committee assignments that carry additional taxpayer-funded compensation.
These stipends are authorized by state law and are standard practice in both parties.
Nevertheless, the combination of secret ballots and financially compensated leadership appointments raises legitimate questions about accountability.
McCombie’s re-election follows significant Republican losses in November, with the House GOP entering the election holding 40 seats and emerging with a substantially smaller caucus.
Despite those losses, 20 Republicans voted to retain McCombie, while 13 supported Deering and one declined to support either candidate.
Secret ballots can protect lawmakers from internal political pressure, but they also prevent constituents from knowing how their representatives voted.
Which 20 Republicans supported McCombie? Which 13 backed Deering? And will lawmakers receiving taxpayer-funded leadership stipends disclose how they voted?
Until individual members voluntarily reveal their positions, voters will have no complete public accounting of the election.
The leadership vote is over. The questions about transparency, taxpayer-funded stipends and accountability are not.






