46.8 F
Friday, December 2, 2022
HomeIllinois NewsThorner: Biden to Forgive Student Loan Debt

Thorner: Biden to Forgive Student Loan Debt


Screen Shot 2022-08-24 at 1.58.41 PM
By Nancy Thorner – 
The Biden administration is expected to announce today, Wednesday, August 24, 2020, a plan to cancel $10,000 of student loan debt for borrowers making $125,000 a year or less.  Biden is also expected to extend the payment pause for federal student loans for several more months.
According to an opinion contributor of The Hill, BEN RITZ, the plan is a terrible idea.  Ritz is director of the Progressive Policy Institute’s Center for Funding America’s Future.
Argues Ritz:  It’s bad politics, and it will further estrange Democrats from working-class voters.
Ritz notes that “only 13 percent of Americans carry any student loan debt, and they have better income and job opportunities than the workers without a degree who will bear the costs.”

Further, the move will likely “backfire with the overwhelming majority of workers who lack college degrees and suburban voters concerned about inflation and government overspending.”
Following are six other reasons Ritz lists why Biden should not cancel student loan debt.
1.  Mass debt cancellation would undermine the Inflation Reduction Act.
2.  Canceling debt for most borrowers is a giveaway to affluent households — paid for by workers.
3.  Student debt cancellation distracts from the real problem of college affordability.
4.  Mass debt cancellation by executive order sets a dangerous precedent.
5.  Student debt cancellation is bad politics.
6.  There are better tools available to help struggling borrowers.
According to Mr. Ritz,  President Biden has already wiped out more student debt than any other president in history, both through the moratorium on interest accrual (which has effectively canceled roughly $6,000 per borrower to date) and additional forgivenesshis administration has given to certain borrowers.
Biden can also continue providing carefully targeted relief and work to expand and reform income-driven repayment programs that directly tie debt cancellation to a borrower’s ability to pay. 
However, the more debt that is rightfully canceled through these mechanisms, the clearer it becomes that there is little justification for canceling the remaining balance.
Read Ritz’s column here: Six reasons Biden should not cancel student debt


- Never miss a story with notifications

- Gain full access to our premium content

- Browse free from up to 5 devices at once

Latest stories

IL GOP Establishment to Grassroots: Only Rich, Donor Voices Matter

By Illinois ReviewIn private messages, social media posts and...

FL Rep. Byron Donalds to IL GOP Elite: You Don’t Win Elections

By Illinois ReviewOAK BROOK, IL - Speaking to a...

Twitter Poll: 93% Favor a New IL GOP Chairman, 7% Oppose

By Illinois Review In an unscientific Twitter poll conducted...

Opinion: Love Your Neighbor for Life, Not Just for Votes

By Daniel EhrmanSince the mid-terms there have been murmurs...


  1. Biden’s basis for what is constitutionally legal or not is how strongly he ‘feels’ about it. If Biden thinks something ought to be this way or that, then he doesn’t care what the law (US Constitution) says or the reasons it was written that way. Biden, you act dictatorially and in a traitorous manner, your lust for power is tyrannical. Biden, you cannot unilaterally forgive student loan debt. That authority belongs to congress.
    Something just occurred to me, I think Biden may be guilty of ex post facto. All the student loans are contractual agreements;
    No Bill of Attainder or ex post facto Law shall be passed. Both federal and state governments are prohibited from enacting ex post facto laws

  2. In Federalist 44, Madison wrote: 1. “No State shall enter into any treaty, alliance, or confederation; grant letters of marque and reprisal; coin money; emit bills of credit; make any thing but gold and silver a legal tender in payment of debts; pass any bill of attainder, ex-post-facto law, or law impairing the obligation of contracts; or grant any title of nobility.”
    1828 Webster’s says ex post facto is: after the fact, RETROACTIVELY

  3. After more study, I see that Biden’s E.O. is not an ex post Facto.
    But since student loan debt forgiveness is not an enumerated power contained in the US Constitution, the federal govt can’t lawfully enact Executive orders (law) impairing the Obligation of Contracts. Its unlawful for the president or congress to forgive loan debt