• Home
  • Illinois News
  • Illinois Politics
  • US Politics
  • US NEWS
  • America First
  • Opinion
  • World News
  • Second Amendment
Saturday, July 5, 2025
Illinois Review
  • Login
  • Register
  • Home
  • Illinois News
  • Illinois Politics
  • US Politics
  • US NEWS
  • America First
  • Opinion
  • World News
  • Second Amendment
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Illinois News
  • Illinois Politics
  • US Politics
  • US NEWS
  • America First
  • Opinion
  • World News
  • Second Amendment
No Result
View All Result
Illinois Review
No Result
View All Result
Home Illinois News

Reeder: What will Neil Gorsuch do in the union dues case?

Illinois Review by Illinois Review
March 2, 2018
in Illinois News
Reading Time: 3 mins read
A A
0
26
SHARES
432
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

2017-02-01T013510Z_138932668_HT1ED2104E51H_RTRMADP_3_USA-COURT-TRUMP-1

You might also like

Chicago AM560 Axes Local Morning Radio Personality Amy Jacobson, Keeps Florida-based Host in Cost-Cutting Move

JB Pritzker Receives 2% in Presidential Poll, Ranks Lowest in Minority Support Among Democrats

Trump’s Jobs Boom Skips Illinois—Thanks to Pritzker’s Tax Hikes

By Scott Reeder - 

SPRINGFIELD – What will Neil Gorsuch do?

The Supreme Court Justice was mum Monday as the U.S. Supreme Court debated an Illinois case that will likely affect organized labor for decades to come.

The case is Janus vs. AFSCME and it originated with an Illinois state worker. At stake is whether government workers should, as a condition of employment, be compelled to pay money to a union. Illinois is one of 22 states that allows this to happen.

Mark Janus, a 65-year-old child support specialist, lives in Springfield and thinks this is wrong.  He filed the lawsuit that is now being considered by the high court. Lawyers like to make things complicated. But here is the bottom line: Should anyone be forced to fund political activity they don’t agree with?

Let’s say you support gun control. Would you want to have money taken out of your paycheck every week to fund the National Rifle Association? I didn’t think so.

Now, the unions will contend that workers can opt not to pay the portion of their dues that funds political activity. Well, that is sorta, kinda true. But not really. Yes, workers can opt out of the portion of dues that get funneled to the political war chests of politicians supported by unions by just paying agency or “fair share” fees to the union. But the problem is that everything involving government is political.

"Everything that is collectively bargained with the government is within the political sphere," the late Justice Antonin Scalia said during arguments in a 2016 case.

In that case which was brought by California teacher Rebecca Friedrichs identical arguments were made before the court.

Based on the questions asked by the justices, many courtroom observers believed the court would rule in her favor. And then Justice Antonin Scalia died. The court ended up deadlocked with a four-four vote and failed to issue an opinion. Since the legal issues are the same, many legal observers believe Scalia’s replacement, Justice Neil Gorsuch, will cast the deciding vote in the Janus case.

All eyes were on the rookie justice Monday hoping to get an idea of how he might vote. He kept his cards close to his vest and didn’t say a word.

The four liberal judges on the court, bemoaned what impact a ruling in Janus’ favor might have on organized labor.

“You’re basically arguing, ‘Do away with unions’,” Justice Sonia Sotomayor said. 

It’s a silly argument on her part. After all, organized labor exists and continues to have influence in the majority of states that do not have compulsory union fees. But organized labor could lose influence if the high court rules in favor of Janus.

Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg said it would be natural for union members to say “I would rather keep the money in my own pocket,” which would cut union revenues. Ginsburg is right that it would natural reaction of most workers.

So if the high court rules in favor of Janus, unions will have to prove to each of their workers that they are worth the money, Is that such a bad thing?

Scott Reeder is a veteran statehouse journalist. He works as a freelance reporter in the Springfield area and produces the podcast Suspect Convictions. He can be reached at [email protected].

Related

Share10Tweet7
Previous Post

Illinois House votes to raise semi-automatic firearm purchases to 21

Next Post

Di Leo: The False Promise of Tariff-Driven Prosperity

Illinois Review

Illinois Review

Founded in 2005, Illinois Review is the leading perspective and source of conservative news, opinion and information in Illinois. Follow Illinois Review on X at @IllinoisReview.

Recommended For You

Chicago AM560 Axes Local Morning Radio Personality Amy Jacobson, Keeps Florida-based Host in Cost-Cutting Move

by Illinois Review
July 1, 2025
0
Chicago AM560 Axes Local Morning Radio Personality Amy Jacobson, Keeps Florida-based Host in Cost-Cutting Move

By Illinois ReviewIn a shocking cost-cutting move Tuesday, Chicago’s AM560 The Answer terminated longtime morning host Amy Jacobson, as the struggling conservative station grapples with declining relevance –...

Read moreDetails

JB Pritzker Receives 2% in Presidential Poll, Ranks Lowest in Minority Support Among Democrats

by Illinois Review
June 30, 2025
0
JB Pritzker Receives 2% in Presidential Poll, Ranks Lowest in Minority Support Among Democrats

By Illinois ReviewIn one of the first nationwide hypothetical polls for the 2028 Democratic presidential primary, Illinois Governor and billionaire JB Pritzker ranks at the bottom, receiving the...

Read moreDetails

Trump’s Jobs Boom Skips Illinois—Thanks to Pritzker’s Tax Hikes

by Thomas Mccullagh
June 26, 2025
0
Trump’s Jobs Boom Skips Illinois—Thanks to Pritzker’s Tax Hikes

Illinois is missing out on Trump’s U.S. manufacturing boom. While other states welcome new factories, Pritzker’s tax hikes and regulations keep businesses out—and force longtime employers to leave.

Read moreDetails

Opinion: We’ll Save You If We See You Burning

by Janelle Powell
June 21, 2025
0
Opinion: We’ll Save You If We See You Burning

By Janelle Powell, Opinion ContributorIn a dazzling display of bureaucratic brilliance, the City of Chicago has rolled out a new policy for the Chicago Fire Department that essentially...

Read moreDetails

Caught Off Guard: Pritzker Left Speechless on Women’s Restroom Question Amid Sanctuary City Testimony

by Illinois Review
June 12, 2025
0
Caught Off Guard: Pritzker Left Speechless on Women’s Restroom Question Amid Sanctuary City Testimony

By Illinois ReviewIllinois Gov. JB Pritzker testified Wednesday before the U.S. House Oversight and Government Reform Committee alongside fellow sanctuary city governors – occasionally appearing visibly stunned and...

Read moreDetails
Next Post

Di Leo: The False Promise of Tariff-Driven Prosperity

Please login to join discussion

Best Dental Group

Related News

IL Freedom Caucus calls on Lurie Children’s Hospital to cease gender services for kids

October 27, 2022

Beckman: Is the Brigham Young University racial slur controversy another hoax?

October 27, 2022

Salvi polling shows closer race

October 27, 2022

Browse by Category

  • America First
  • Education
  • Faith & Family
  • Foreign Policy
  • Health Care
  • Illinois News
  • Illinois Politics
  • Opinion
  • Science
  • Second Amendment
  • TRENDING
  • US NEWS
  • US Politics
  • World News
Illinois Review

© 2024 llinois Review LLC Editor in Chief Mark Vargas Publisher Thomas McCullagh Chief Counsel Scott Kaspar

Navigate Site

  • Checkout
  • Home
  • Home – mobile
  • Login/Register
  • Login/Register
  • My account
  • My Account-
  • My Account- – mobile

Follow Us

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Illinois News
  • Illinois Politics
  • US Politics
  • Health Care
  • US NEWS
  • America First
  • Opinion
  • TRENDING
  • Education
  • Foreign Policy
  • Second Amendment
  • Faith & Family
  • Science
  • World News

© 2024 llinois Review LLC Editor in Chief Mark Vargas Publisher Thomas McCullagh Chief Counsel Scott Kaspar

Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?